Cyber Security Predictions for 2017

2016 was a big year in the annals of Cyber Security, and 2017 promises to eclipse it.

Creating an Enterprise Data Strategy

An introduction to the process of developing comprehensive strategies for enterprise data manangement and exploitation.

A Framework for Evolutionary Artificial Thought

Let’s start at the beginning – what does this or any such “Framework” buy us?

The Innovation Dilemma

What things actually promote or discourage innovation? We'll examine a few in this post...

Digitial Transformation, Defined

Digitial Transformation is a hot topic in IT and big money maker for consultants - but what does it really mean?.

Showing posts with label time travel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label time travel. Show all posts

Monday, June 3, 2013

Deconstructing Time - part 3: Reference Frames

In our past two posts on time, we began to outline some key concepts, most notably the notion of an “event.” Today we’re going to try to add some more context to the discussion and then talk about “Frames.”

A Contextual Dilemma
Let’s say NASA made a breakthrough in propulsion and in its ability to secure some funding (the real miracle perhaps). A mission is being planned to the nearest star that is believed to have an earth-like planet, Kepler 10b. This star system is approximately 500 light years from Earth. In basic terms, this means that the light that we see today emanating from Kepler 10b is not from that star’s present, but from 500 years in its past. We can somewhat accurately plot where Kepler 10b is now as well as all of its locations along its journey between 500 years ago and its “now.” (because it is travelling on a stable course – at least it has been up to the point we’ve been able to witness in its 500 years ago – who knows – aliens from Alpha Centauri could have blown up the whole star system 200 years ago in their time, there is no way for us to know for sure).

NASA artist conception of Kepler 10b
So, you might be thinking it’s obvious that we would be travelling to the “Now” version of Kepler 10b, right? Well maybe it’s not so obvious. Let’s assume that a propulsion approach better than today’s has been discovered providing us speeds up to 20,000 km/s.  This still doesn't come anywhere close to light speed. At this better yet still sluggish speed, it would take our astronauts more than 16,000 years to arrive at the Kepler 10b star system. This obviously doesn't equate to the Now we just extrapolated for Kepler 10b just a moment ago – the ‘Now’ that is equivalent to the distance it traveled since the light we see on Earth's now was generated (500 years ago).

What if we were able to travel at or close to the speed of light (or faster than light)? According to Special Relativity, if we are travelling at close to the speed of light (say 97% or so) then the actual time it takes to arrive at Kepler 10b is 12 years (in travel time felt by the astronauts). For folks back on Earth, 502 years will have passed. So, which Kepler 10b do we arrive at then if we're travelling that fast(important to know so we’re actually pointed at where/when it will be)? Let’s see if we can guess:

  1. It’s not the Kepler 10b from which the original light we were looking at came from.
  2. It’s not the Kepler 10b that is in the same instance of Now as Earth is. (this is a complex topic and we will explore it in more depth soon).
  3. It’s not the Kepler 10b that it would have taken us 16,000 years to reach. (because we close to light speed)
  4. It may be the Kelper 10b roughly 12 years after the point we measured the 500 year light old from Earth and determined when was Kepler's Now (in other words 512 years or 12 years into Kepler 10b's future). Or, it may not be.

The reason that there is some uncertainty relates to the fact that all of our measurements are being generated based on time as defined in Earth or near-Earth contexts. We are also assuming (perhaps incorrectly) that Earth and Kepler 10b are moving away from one another at a constant speed. There are some galaxies that despite universal expansion are moving towards one another.

Why would any of this be important? Well, say we were dealing with a typical Science Fiction scenario where people from Earth were preparing to making a first contact with a race of intelligent beings whom were on the verge of discovering atomic energy. In that situation, showing up even five years too late might be devastating, but it would also be somewhat embarrassing if we showed up several hundred years early as well (to witness the invention of the rifled musket instead).

Events occur within Reference Frames (a two dimensional visualization of a multi-dimensional phenomenon)

The invention of a weapon might be viewed as an event as would be any number of activities involved with traveling between Earth and Kepler 10b. Finding the events (across both time and space and across significant distances in space) is a tricky business. One way to help better understand events and how to locate them is by placing them in the context of Reference Frame.

Here is the Wikipedia definition:
In physics, a frame of reference (or reference frame) may refer to a coordinate system used to represent and measure properties of objects such as their position and orientation. It may also refer to a set of axes used for such representation. 
Alternatively, in relativity, the phrase can be used to refer to the relationship between a moving observer and the phenomenon or phenomena under observation. In this context, the phrase often becomes "observational frame of reference" (or "observational reference frame"). The context may itself include a coordinate system used to represent the observer and phenomenon or phenomena.
The Reference Frame is the timespace box within which an event or events occurs. The box though is not limited to 3 three dimensional geometry as it exists across time and space. In fact, the box really doesn't exist at all except in the context of providing a conceptual grid field that allows us to distinguish events from each other. The other key aspect of a Frame is that it allows us to define the boundary for Simultaneity.

Frames don't always move in the same direction...
Sorry for tossing in another new term so quickly – but it’s a key one that helps us to cement events within frames. Simultaneity is often viewed or described in purely relativistic terms, but here we’re going to view it a bit more broadly. Simultaneity is the Now that corresponds to an event within a frame or frames. Simultaneity is usually restricted by the ability to pass information back and forth between observers at the speed of light, C. In the old days, this represented information that could be seen directly – nowadays it can be a live internet video conference between Dayton, Ohio and Tokyo, Japan. This live conference may be occurring 12 time zones apart and the folks in either city would be sitting in a different calendar day than the participants in the other city. Yet, the event is synchronized through a global agreement on the tracking of Terrestrial time (Greenwich Mean Time - GMT) and communications that are passing across satellites and phone lines at roughly the speed of light. So, even though it may be 6:00 pm in Dayton and 7:00 a.m. tomorrow in Toyko, the meeting is a simultaneous event which occurs in the same reference frame.

This is curious even at our own limited scale here on Earth, isn’t it? The people in Dayton are in effect travelling into tomorrow to attend the meeting and the folks in Toyko are going back in time – strictly speaking. In a larger sense, all of us, in Toyko, Ohio and the rest of the planet are travelling forward through time in a sequential, linear manner. So, we have already proved that time travel does indeed exist, sort of.

But let’s get back to Reference Frames; here’s our definition of what they are:
A Reference Frame is the logical boundary within which an event or events may occur. The Frame exhibits (approximate) Simultaneity for the events and participants within and can be used to provide a coordinate system for tracking events. 
The biggest difference between my definition and that associated with Relativity Theory surrounds the use of the word “Logical.” By adding this we allow much more flexibility to the concept. Let’s say for example someone invented a quantum communications system between Earth and Mars. Instead of each transmission taking 8 minutes to send, the communication would be instantaneous (or worse, a reply might be received before a message was sent – we’ll talk about that eventually).

Thus a news conference with our Mars exploration team could become a simultaneous event occurring within one very large (for us) Reference Frame. Let’s add some other characteristics for Frames while we’re at it:

  • Frames can last for indefinite duration.
  • Frames can overlap.
  • Frames generally exist in the same time phase or phase space (more on that later).
  • Frames expand and collapse – there isn’t a fixed grid in timespace – only the potential for one, when potential is realized, frames appear (or more accurately can be discovered).
  • Frames are supported under both classical and relativistic physics – they may also be supported by Quantum physics but we may never be able to assign coordinates at that scale.
  • Frames are by their nature, multi-dimensional.
  • Events can be linked within and across frames through “Continuity Paths.”

In conclusion for today’s post I’d like to leave you all with one key thought – the context of the trip I provided earlier makes it clear that any significant travel into Space is in fact an exercise in both Space and Time travel. Why that’s the case is the topic of our next post.



copyright 2013, Stephen Lahanas

Saturday, June 1, 2013

Deconstructing Time - part 2 "Events"

In the last post, I introduced a new line of dialog for Technovation Talks and provided my own "frame of reference" for how the investigation may proceed. This post will be used to begin quantifying Time. I think most people probably have a sense that this is something that has already been figured out. However, the deeper you dive into the topic, the less clear it seems to get. And any lack of clarity would make it difficult if not impossible to create reproducible mechanisms for identifying events.

We'll start by defining "Event."

Here's the Wikipedia definition:
In physics, and in particular relativity, an event indicates a physical situation or occurrence, located at a specific point in space and time. For example, a glass breaking on the floor is an event; it occurs at a unique place and a unique time, in a given frame of reference. 
Strictly speaking, the notion of an event is an idealization, in the sense that it specifies a definite time and place, whereas any actual event is bound to have a finite extent, both in time and in space. One of the goals of relativity is to specify the possibility of one event influencing another. 
I'm focusing on Events to begin with because I believe this is perhaps the most likely way to help identify paths and or coordinates within spacetime. The use of the term Event in this context is generally associated with the modern view of time - e.g. time as described in the context of both Special and General Relativity (although surprise, surprise Einstein's two theories don't exactly agree with each other on this topic and neither of them have been reconciled yet with quantum physics). Events are also mostly ignored in the previous accepted paradigm defined by Newton  - known as Absolute Time. Here's how Sir Issac described it:
Absolute, true and mathematical time, of itself, and from its own nature flows equably without regard to anything external, and by another name is called duration: relative, apparent and common time, is some sensible and external (whether accurate or unequable) measure of duration by the means of motion, which is commonly used instead of true time.
nice scarf, Issac...
It's worth noting here that there was disagreement on this definition almost immediately after it was introduced and that debate was one of the key factors in helping to drive modern theory. So Newton accounts for the possibility of events but relates them to what he calls "common time." Interestingly, also he contends that absolute time is independent of motion, sort of an a priori view of time - time is as time may be defined in its own right, or time as a constant.  A constant is a measure - but an event is that which is measured which is why we're starting there.

Beyond the initial description of what an event is an abstract sense, there isn't any agreed upon definition as to what an event in physics actually represents. Without that understanding that it is highly unlikely that we could ever define precise/distinct events or come close to pinpointing them in any sort of consistent fashion. So let's revisit the definition of an event by first attributing some more characteristics to it:

  • An event is dynamic. In other words, there is no standard duration or scope bounding any given event.
  • Events can occur at multiple levels of context. This can extend from the subatomic level up through to a universal scale. Those levels of context can become a more or less de facto Event Taxonomy.
  • Events are grouped within reference frames, those frames inhabit all levels of context (in varying sizes).
  • An event requires at least one entity and in most cases two in order to occur. (I'll explain this is more detail later - situations with only one involve humans).
  • An event involves some interchange of energy. On the atomic scale this could be visualized as electrons colliding, on the cellular it could be white blood cells engulfing bacteria and absorbing their energy or on our scale it might be more subtle - one action impacts the causality chain of others (some within the same frame of reference, others outside of it). There is the possibility that this interchange may provide some sort of identifiable signature (not unlike some of the phenomena we search for in subatomic physics when looking for new particles we think exist but haven't captured or detected yet).
  • All events have a beginning and end point, however events can overlap and events can be chained together in a variety of different ways. Event chains can also follow distinct trajectories within timespace called "event paths" (or 'continuity paths' - more on that later).
  • Events occur within a given time phase (that phase is a combination of a number of factors including frame, context and information velocity).
  • Measuring an event impacts or changes that event. In other words, the Heisenberg principle applies. 
  • The duration of an event is dictated by the duration required to complete any given interaction or set of interactions. 
  • No two events are exactly the same. 
  • Events inhabit a specific, definable region of spacetime - however this region (or set of coordinates as the event moves along with spacetime) cannot be accurately identified using the current method for assigning location in 4 dimensional spacetime (4 vector coordinates - more on that later).
  • Human perception adds a number of complications to the nature of events that must be resolved if we ever intend to develop consistent framework for understanding them. For example, determinations of how to group or separate events will at first be a somewhat subjective exercise - as an example of that I've included an illustration of a somewhat arbitrary framework for doing it directly below.  
  • If we accept some of the key precepts of relativity and current evidence it is clear that events from past, present and future can exist in one simultaneous frame of reference, at least indirectly (more on this later).
  • Events exhibit simultaneity - in others words, the entities within it share a 'now' which is defined by the ability to synchronize information across / over the span of the event. This is typically described in physics as the ability to transmit information using light thus it is bounded by the C or constant speed of light.  

This represent a potential way to stack or organize events...
Based on these characteristics then, here is a somewhat modified base definition for "Event:"
An event is an identifiable portion of spacetime, characterized by the interaction of entities within its scope of relative simultaneity.  
I've noted that scope is bounded by relative simultaneity for two reasons:

  1. That for human entities / observers, simultaneity can extend to significant distances through use of technology. (more on that later). 
  2. That at the Quantum or subatomic level, (and potentially at the universal level) information exchange is not restricted by C. 

In our next post we talk a little bit about travelling to a nearby star and its implications to our views of spacetime and introduce reference frames in more detail.



copyright 2013, Stephen  Lahanas

Deconstructing Time - part 1

We're going to expand the scope of our examinations here on Technovation Talks to include dialogs on more fundamental topics related to science, technology and innovation. We will begin this new chapter in our blog by launching a discussion about Time. This dialog will investigate both current thinking and its gaps as well as the technological implications of our ever-evolving understanding regarding the nature of time.

Deconstructing Time - Part 1: An Introduction
I tend to work as a consultant - the scope of that work encompasses Information Technology, but the methodology and nature of that type of work can be applied to any problem space. In my opinion, the type of methodology we tend to use today in most IT projects is considerably more flexible (or Agile) than those used for most other professions. This wasn't always the case. From the 1950's to the 1980's Information Systems (IS) as a practice area was much more rigid. The reason why it was more rigid was the relative pace of innovation, which during that time period was substantially slower than it is today. If we were able to plot both quantity of technological change and the rate of acceleration of that change would become even more obvious why less rigid thinking was needed. Beginning in the 1990's, the pace of change reached a critical mass - IS became IT - and this lead to an explosion of jobs in the IT field and the introduction of many people who hadn't initially viewed IT as a career opportunity.  

From the perspective of this new influx of people, the attraction to this evolving field included:
  • The ability to define technology.
  • The ability to help define new fields of practice. 
  • The freedom to think 'out of the box' - creativity is rewarded in IT now more often than it is in most other fields.
  • The ability to apply IT to help redefine everything else in society. 
IT is the place to be for people who want to exercise innovation on a regular basis. I'm not saying that innovation doesn't occur in other fields, it certainly does, the difference may be in how hard one has to fight to achieve it elsewhere as compared to IT. The phenomena behind what I'm describing is not unique to recent history - it simply reflects the nature of collective consensus - in other words once key concepts are well defined, a community unites behind them. Concepts become 'institutionalized' and entry into the community (of practice) requires adherence to those concepts. Questioning the foundational concepts of the group is generally discouraged - or at the very least only permitted within restricted parameters. IT stands out today in that entry into the group is very informal and questioning of premises is tolerated because the premises or fundamental approaches are in a constant state of flux.
So, what does all this have to with Time? Well, what I'm proposing in this series of posts is to reexamine current assumptions in regards to how we view Time as a construct and to apply my IT-related methodology to that 'problem space.' This is both a theoretical and practical exercise. It's theoretical because we are challenging and hopefully changing some key assumptions and practical in that this modified world-view will have a number of practical (and maybe not so practical applications).

Disclaimer - what will follow in this series is a layman's description of the problem space; the intent is not to provide mathematical proofs but rather to illustrate conceptual alternatives. This is not altogether different than how I would approach a problem strictly associated with IT (we don't express design logic in binary format or assembly language but rather through the abstraction the design elements into conceptual or logical terms).

We will use a tailored or specialized version of our typical IT methodology - it is based on assessing topics in the context of problem space. Our problem space for this exploration is complex time-space coordinate mapping or travel. The central question is this - how does one locate an event in time/space?  In order to answer this, I've constructed an approach through the following steps:
  1. Re-examination of core assumptions regarding time (or TimeSpace). The expectation is that this will lead to some redefinition of the topic matter.
  2. Determine of an approach for coordinate mapping for event location. 
  3. Assess current (design) patterns for travel within SpaceTime.
  4. Create updated patterns for travel within SpaceTime.
  5. Explore potential applications for the modified assumptions and new patterns.

Our segue into the following post is the definition of Time itself. What is it? Here's what Merriam Webster says:
Measured or measurable period. More broadly, it is a continuum that lacks spatial dimensions. Philosophers have sought an understanding of time by focusing on the broad questions of the relation between time and the physical world and the relation between time and consciousness. Those who adopt an absolutist theory of time regard it as a kind of container within which the universe exists and change takes place, and believe that its existence and properties are independent of the physical universe. According to the rival relationist theory, time is nothing over and above change in the physical universe. Largely because of Albert Einstein, it is now held that time cannot be treated in isolation from space (see space-time). Some argue that Einstein's theories of relativity vindicate relationist theories, others that they vindicate the absolutist theory. The primary issue concerning the relation between time and consciousness is the extent, if any, to which time or aspects of time depend on the existence of conscious beings. Events in time are normally thought of in terms of notions of past, present, and future, which some philosophers treat as mind-dependent; others believe that time is independent of perception and hold that past, present, and future are objective features of the world. See also geologic time, Greenwich Mean Time, standard time, Universal Time.
Other searches will trawl in many more definitions; dozens, even hundreds of them and of course many books have been dedicated to the subject. But perhaps some of these definitions are too complicated to get the topic started  so let's identify characteristics that tend to be related to Time in one fashion or another; these include:
  • Time is something that is perceived.
  • Time is something that is measurable.
  • Time seems to be related to space.
  • Time seems to be related to motion, distance and velocity.
  • Time may be relative to the perspective from which it measured or perceived. 
  • Time appears to be linear.
  • Time has both 'local' and 'global' contexts - e.g. it seems scalable.
  • Time may or may not be a physical construct.
  • Time seems to break down at both the subatomic and universal scale (e.g. big bang)
The next post will take a deeper dive into the definitions of Time.



copyright 2013, Stephen  Lahanas