Cyber Security Predictions for 2017

2016 was a big year in the annals of Cyber Security, and 2017 promises to eclipse it.

Creating an Enterprise Data Strategy

An introduction to the process of developing comprehensive strategies for enterprise data manangement and exploitation.

A Framework for Evolutionary Artificial Thought

Let’s start at the beginning – what does this or any such “Framework” buy us?

The Innovation Dilemma

What things actually promote or discourage innovation? We'll examine a few in this post...

Digitial Transformation, Defined

Digitial Transformation is a hot topic in IT and big money maker for consultants - but what does it really mean?.

Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts

Sunday, December 11, 2016

Technology & The 2016 Election part 5: Voter Beware

This is the last in my series of posts on how Technology influenced the 2016 election. As I write this, new articles keep streaming out in relation to Fake News, Russian hacking and transition appointments. While we may have hoped that after the election had finished, things might cool down – it seems that presumption may have been premature. In the previous posts, I discussed specific technologies, trends and tactics but what does it all mean for us the voters? Few of us wish to be or are qualified to be pundits, we just want to do our civic duty with the least amount of drama and hassle possible – yet drama and hassle seem to be looming large in everyone’s future. What if anything can we as voters do?
In some ways, such as how candidates are selected, things have changed little...
This is probably the toughest question of them all and we know it’s one that’s not being answered as more and more people get turned off from the political process. I think there may two tracks here in terms of the types of things we as voters can do to prepare for and ultimately (or hopefully) improve the process…
Track 1 – Voter Beware
This is a slight turn on the phrase “buyer beware,” but the analogy seems a good one. In coming years, we ought to try to get more savvy in regards to how all politicians – from every side – are trying to manipulate us one way or the other.  Politicians and ideas are products in many ways; they’re advertised like them, we buy them to make ourselves better and when we’re sick of them we discard them and trade up for newer models. Now, maybe I’m being a bit too cynical here, but there are some upsides to viewing this as a Consumerism. Consumers, for one thing, often take more time investigating which brands to buy and actually comparison shop as opposed to sticking with the same thing out of loyalty year open year. Consumers even use unbiased guides to help them wade though the false claims of many products to get at the truth because ultimately, buying the right product can save you a lot of money.
The saving money part is actually an even better analogy to the political process given that the choices we make in elections probably effect our pocketbooks more than all of the comparison shopping we’ll ever do. This year has given us some valid and interesting motivations for perhaps becoming a little more skeptical and judicious when we listen to the political promises of politicians. This year we’ve seen how much pure propaganda has been used to confuse or manipulate us, we’ve seen that raw sentiment (either negative or positive) might not always be the best basis for making a decision. Another way of putting that might be, that if you’re voting against something chances are you really don’t appreciate or understand what it is you’re really voting for. That’s a bit like buying a Jeep instead of a F150 when you really wanted a Prius – it just doesn’t make any sense and if everyone does that it is quite likely that most people will end up unsatisfied to some degree. Here are a couple of other pragmatic suggestions:
  • Don’t get all of your news off Facebook
  • Look for unbiased sources and combine those with the ones you trust already and see what the comparisons really look like from different perspectives
  • Don’t let anyone think for you. Take the time to research yourself.
  • Don’t let anyone discourage you from voting. It’s not just a right or a privilege – it’s an obligation. If the majority of Americans hold their nose in disgust but choose not to participate, then they’ve lost the right to complain about the outcome (which of course they likely will).
  • Demand more of your candidate or party. Don’t let them sink further into ambiguous, abbreviated explanations. They will continue to try to win you over with Twitter but we all know that no one can hold an intelligent conversation using 140 characters or less and no one should treat the American people as if they’re too dumb to go beyond that.
Track 2 – What Could We Change?
If I had to pick one problem which looms above all others at least at the presidential level, it wouldn’t be the electoral college (although that’s not so great), rather it is the way we choose candidates in our party system. There are several huge problems here, including:
  • A closed system that prevents the vast majority of interested, qualified people from ever participating
  • The same system also prevents of us from participating until after all the real choices are made – and then we’re just stuck with it
  • A lock on the main two parties with almost no ability for 3rd parties to gain access. A perfect example of this are the uneven rules that nearly every state requires for candidates to get on the ballot – 3rd party candidates typically require 1,000’s more signatures making it nearly impossible for them to even join a national race
I’ve highlighted these issues specifically because I think one of the most annoying aspects of our system seems to be the lack of actual choice we have as voters, which in turn leaves us with the feeling that it’s the same cast of characters over and over again. And truthfully, that feeling is pretty accurate – for a nation of over 300 hundred million people, we’ve got a tiny handful of what seem to be the same people running everything. Those of us who want change and see the same people doing the same things across administrations and across parties once they get elected, tend to get frustrated. That’s perhaps one explanation for what happened this year.
I’ve got another suggestion though, one that could be fueled by technology but hasn’t happened yet. Most states and districts allow for “write-in” candidates. If the traditional parties do not want to open up (and occasionally they do but usually only for billionaires, otherwise it seems as though the Backroom approach is still going strong); then why not translate the practical experience gained from all sorts of Internet activism and turn that into a new form of political party – a Logical Party. “Logical” not because it makes any particular sense (although hopefully it would), but Logical in the sense that it would be “Virtual” and exist only as an online community. This Logical or Virtual party could then have an open and online selection process (and to be fair there are some places that have started doing this, it’s not entirely new) and it could field candidates both in the presidential race and in state races. Now that would be some real Populism.
And why not? It couldn’t be any worse than 2016, right?

Copyright 2016, Stephen Lahanas

Saturday, December 10, 2016

Technology & The 2016 Election part 4: A New Age for Political Campaigning

In this latest post in our series, we’ll look at how lessons from the 2016 campaign will be applied in all future campaigns – and not just at the national or presidential level…
Will this year’s election change the way campaigns will be run from here on out? In a word, yes. Is this due to any single innovation or any single campaign or candidate? Not really, the trends that emerged this year encompassed new techniques that worked across campaigns as well as old ones that failed unexpectedly in others. Let’s take look at what worked and what didn’t.
What Worked in 2016 across Campaigns? Here are a few items:
  • Platforms as Memes
  • Momentum Building & Fund Raising through Social Media
  • And Free Media
  • Targeted Polling / Selective GOTV / Sentiment Analysis
Platforms & Candidates as Internet Memes – The two candidates who exploited this best were Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump. Both employed what seemed to be odd or unconventional messaging, but messaging that soon took viral flight. ‘Build the wall,’ ‘Feel the Bern’ and “Drain the Swamp” combined with other images or phrases helped to shape campaign identities and build a sense of community among supporters. The successful Memes were ones that harnessed or stoked discontent but discontent that was coming from both ends of the political spectrum. Memes are somewhat complex and a bit difficult to understand for people who are deliberately setting out to create them – they tend to take on a life of their own and are often unpredictable. I suppose a good analogy to what existed before I politics that was somewhat like this were extremely famous campaign jingles or something like the “Daisy Ad.” Memes combine public relations, advertising, political discourse into neat recognizable bundles – a trend that also extended to other aspects of messaging this year.
Exploitation of Social Media as the Primary Channel to Reach Voters - This was new and as noted in a previous post, President Elect Trump is still using it even now as his primary mode of communicating with the electorate. The traditional media establishment wanted to write off both Bernie and Trump so their campaigns both bypassed it and this year – that actually worked. Social media was how all momentum was created in both campaigns and it was well integrated with the rallies. One might think of these campaigns as ‘crowd-sourced politics’ – with each candidate raising most of their funds from small donors (more the case with Bernie than Trump). This latter development was perhaps the most shocking aspect of the campaign given the recent flood of dark money into politics after the Citizens United decision by the Supreme Court in 2010. Had Bernie won instead of the Billionaire Trump, the crowd-sourcing aspect of the election would have taken on much greater significance, potentially heralding an end to big money influence in politics. The fact that Trump used it to win though makes it all the more fascinating.
Free is Good, and now it’s Effective Too – The King of Tabloids knew from the start that a certain type of communications approach was likely to garner non-stop free election coverage. The fact that other candidates were able to generate almost as much attention without sounding quite so sensational was surprising. If effectiveness is measured in how many people hear a message and actually listen, then the free media given to Sanders and Trump definitely eclipsed traditional media buys this year. In some ways, it might be worthwhile to pronounce the traditional campaign ad as obsolete. Although, that might be a bit premature, as some state races saw effective use of television buys as in Ohio. But in the Ohio Senate race for example, it was a traditional media campaign poised against another poorly funded traditional media campaign instead of a proactive social media campaign. In the future, all media will likely start in Social Media and if it expands into Traditional media buys, it will do so as part of a larger campaign still driven from Social Media (to reinforce its effectiveness). For example, the cost of one professionally produced campaign video distributed let’s say on a state level, one could easily create 100 social media videos or podcasts and distribute them free nationally. The fact that media looks perfect isn’t what should be important here – it’s getting the message across to the audience that needs to hear it. If it isn’t as slick as a Hollywood movie so what – if it looks and feels genuine – so much the better.
Zeroing on the Voters – GOTV – We learned in 2016 that getting out the vote can definitely be more efficient and that discouraging the vote is now a widely accepted campaign practice by many and highly effective. The Trump campaign introduced innovations such as use of a mobile app that allowed door-knocking volunteers to register every house they visited and instantly update the information to the Cloud. This combined with a more targeted type of informal polling, designed to help drive tactics and message, made the Trump campaign particularly effective.
What didn’t work in 2016? That includes…
  • Traditional GOTV
  • Traditional Media
  • Traditional Messaging (conservative versus sensational)
We might even add ‘Traditional Candidates’ to the list, as the overall mode for change seemed to imply that as well. Whether national discontent has been stoked beyond the realm of reason or whether it’s been justified is a difficult question. While ordinary Americans have found it hard to get ahead, the country itself has been doing pretty well by all the objective measures used by both parties in the past. Unemployment for example is down to some of the lowest levels in terms of jobless claims since the 1970’s. This is all the more incredible considering we were on the brink of a Depression in 2008. Be that as it may, though, the perception this year was that government is ineffective and the usual cast of suspects were – well suspect. That led to a lot of what had worked before to fail utterly this year.
Traditional GOTV – The key part of this phrase is Get Out, if your voters do not go out and vote, the candidate doesn’t win. This year there were also some fundamental errors made in terms of where to focus the GOTV efforts. The Clinton campaign lost crucial votes from minority communities and women and focused perhaps too much on trying to shore up their union and white working base. This may sound counter-intuitive given all of the commentary after the election about how Clinton lost the white working class male vote. But the fact remains and should have been recognized by the Clinton campaign that she had really lost that vote and should not have wasted time knocking on many doors that turned out to belong to Trump supporters. This was evidence of poor internal polling and an inability to quickly adjust to changing circumstances. In the 3 swing states where recounts were requested, the difference in women, African Americans and Latinos who didn’t vote at all may have carried each of those states for Clinton had she been able to get them out of the house. Previous technology innovations such as Robo-Calling weren’t working so well this year and the Clinton campaign did a relatively poor job of generating enthusiasm in much of the party base. Some of this was due to the harsh Primary but some of it was also a lack of understanding in how to properly use technology to help organize, motivate and target voters.
Traditional Media Didn’t Work – Clinton’s slick media campaign lacked the personal touch that made Bernie more accessible and Trump more exciting. Anything that was too polished, too familiar this year, was likely to remind the voters of how often they’d seen professional politics played before. That didn’t go over so well this election cycle and may not ever again. It seemed at times that the Clinton strategy was to stay above the fray and play it safe, allowing a flood of attacks to go unanswered on social media or traditional media (and using traditional media to try to respond to all of that would have been impractical).
Traditional Messaging Didn’t Work – We’ve gotten used to vague political messages that often didn’t connect with our personal concerns or interests. However, vague personal messaging seem to work pretty well. Those who made their messages more personal this year and found a way to deliver them in a more direct manner, did exceptionally well. Even if you weren’t an insider, sounding like an insider was problematic this year. This is all very understandable though if we consider that people seldom have the opportunity to communicate with their elected representatives – any message or medium that allows there to be a sense that two-way communication is happening is likely to be well-received.
Another reason traditional messaging didn’t work well this year is that the dynamic Social Media driven campaigns of Sanders and Trump understood how to condense their messaging to levels never before experienced in American politics. What does that mean? Didn’t every campaign since Washington’s depend on relatively simplistic slogans? Well, yes and no. In the past there was both the shorthand and the detailed message. The slogans, posters, ads and jingles were the shorthand – but there was generally real substance backing all of that up. This year, in the Trump campaign in particular, substance was viewed as a liability and largely disregarded – it was truly the Twitter platform. Every issue had to be explained in 140 characters or less, with little or no expectation for further elaboration.
From this point forward, we’ll see several important trends emerging in nearly every political campaign for better or worse:
  1. Communications / Media directors will now probably be referred to as Social Media Directors and all communications will be coordinated in that context.
  2. Voter polling and targeting within campaigns will become more selective and more accurate – with a focus on ensuring that the solid base is turned out with less concern about the margins. The margins will likely be dealt with more through messaging than with GOTV.
  3. Messaging will also be likely dedicated in most campaigns to discourage the margins and some of the opposing base to vote at all. While Negative campaigning is nothing new, the art of increasing the opponent’s negative ratings has reached all time heights this year and it’s unlikely that this type of success will be ignored. And more candidates will follow the trend to “Twitterize” their platforms.
  4. Campaign litigation will increase. As more voter suppression laws proliferate and Gerrymandering becomes more prevalent, the focus of election contests for decades to come will address both election outcomes and the underlying electoral systems themselves. It is important to note that at this time, there is one side in American politics that is consistently behind voter suppression but that’s not to say that someday things couldn’t flip – it’s happened before. Campaigns will be facing these types of issues in nearly every election from now on, so if you thought this campaign might finally put an end to the age of Hyper-Controversy, think again, it’s just starting.
In my next post and the last in this series, I’m going to look at how all of these types of changes will impact you the voter and how you can prepare for it in upcoming elections.

Copyright 2016, Stephen Lahanas

Sunday, December 4, 2016

Technology & Election 2016 part 3 – The Failure of Data Science?

The first reaction on election night, November 8th, 2016 was – what, how did that happen? The entire country and in fact the whole world was more or less shocked at the unexpected outcome. But why was it so unexpected? The top level answer to that is simply that nearly every major poll or projection turned out to be wrong. What kind of numbers are we talking about? For example, Nate Silver’s FiveThirtyEight blog projected Clinton to win by about 5% in the popular vote (with 71% certainty). If we drill down to the state polls we see that the projections showed all 3 key turnover states, Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania going to Clinton by 3 to 5% in each contest. This is significant because many of these projections (and blogs like FiveThirtyEight) were using aggregates of dozens or hundreds of polls, not just one or a handful and the differences exceeded the margin of error.
Let’s step back for a moment and talk about the typical role that Data Science plays in the election process today. This role encompasses several well-known and some lessor known functions, including:
  • Predictive polling
  • Exit polling
  • Predictive modeling
  • Vote targeting (which facilitates a sort of CRM for campaign marketing as well as Get Out the Vote efforts)
There’s nothing new about polling, it’s been around for a long time. In fact, the last time there was a collective shock like this year’s outcome was in 1948, when the polls had predicted Dewey would win (by 50 to 45% - but Truman won by 50% to 45%). Polls have improved since then and of course, now we have the benefit of the latest data technology as well as 70 years of added experience, so how did nearly every major poll get it wrong this year? There are some theories; they include the following:
  1. A lot of people changed their minds at the last moment and weren’t particularly firm in their previous opinions.
  2. The Russians did it.
  3. Many polls were not properly targeting prospective voters for their models.
  4. Many people who had said they were voting for Clinton didn’t turn out to vote at all (e.g. the lack of enthusiasm)
  5. The poll numbers for the 3rd party candidates may have been inflated, and when it came to election day these candidates received far fewer votes that had been predicted (the implication being they went ahead and voted for one of the main candidates with Trump being the main beneficiary).
To be honest, we may never have a fully satisfactory answer for what happened in the 2016 election. It is likely that we’ve never had a race where both of the main candidates were universally unpopular and that kind of situation might never happen again (and there’s no telling how that may have impacted the polling results). How do we move forward then? Did technology, did Data Science fail us in 2016? Maybe, but probably not. What we witnessed however is that technology is only as good as our ability to apply it. If situations become more dynamic, complex within a relatively short window, do we stick with what we know or do we adjust our models or practices?
I’d like to step back for a moment here and ask a larger question. Do we really want ironclad predictions before elections in the first place? Before the big upset on election night, many pundits were talking about the lessons learned from the 1980 election where results from the East Coast encouraged West Coast voters to stay home thinking their votes didn’t really count. Because of that, the FEC passed a rule prohibiting networks from announcing winners before certain polls close. Don’t polls predicting a sure outcome before an election have a similar chilling effect? This year for example, how many voters may have stayed home because while they weren’t terribly enthused about Clinton, thought she would win? That’s a hard question to ask because people who don’t show up to vote can’t be interviewed in exit polls (or at least typically aren’t interviewed as part of the election post mortem).
What can we do in Future to avoid getting surprised?
I think it is important that in coming up with suggestions here, we need to weigh the relative value of using a particular solution with the potential impacts of using it. In other words, if we view predictive polling as a relativistic activity (e.g. a bit like Heisenberg’s principle in that taking a measure can influence the outcome), then we might conclude that the highest value of such predictive polls relative to possible harm might end several weeks before the election. How then could we be assured that elections are honest, that public sentiment is in fact aligned with election results? Well, that can still come through exit polling – polls taken of actual voters on election day and in addition, sentiment polls taken the day after the election of potential voters who didn’t vote (something that doesn’t typically happen now).  
Suggestion – Place a moratorium on predictive polls at least 2 weeks prior to election day and preferably 4 weeks prior. Why would this work? Here are few potential benefits of doing it:
  • This has the immediate effect of not making the election as much of a horse race and more of a contest of ideas.
  • It has at least the potential of driving up voter participation – a lot can happen in 4 weeks, people can vote based on their opinions and do a little less hedging in making their decisions.
  • It helps to combat Group-think (people swarming to the anticipated victor or becoming despondent about their own preferred candidates)
  • It certainly eliminates the main source of any potential surprise.
  • It may encourage candidates to take a more expansive view towards courting voters, recent trends have focused way too much attention on potential swing states and districts.
As you can tell, this and potentially other suggestions may have relatively little to do with Data Science itself, but have everything to do with how we apply it to given situations. I don’t believe the technology failed us here, I think we failed to recognize how much it already influences election outcomes. In my next post in this series, I’ll talk a bit more about Get Out the Vote (GOTV), politics as demographics and how technology has been and will be used to manage campaigns.

Copyright 2016, Stephen Lahanas 

Tuesday, October 16, 2012

The Architecture of Debate

Tonight marks the second presidential debate in election 2012. Many people are thinking about who will perform and who won't, but how many are talking about the architecture of this week's debate? Sounds a bit strange doesn't it; but believe it or not one can apply the principles of Architecture to just about everything and Debate is no exception. What this statement implies is that there is in fact an organized structure behind every debate (despite whatever performances are turned in by the candidates), and several structures if you really think about it:
  1. The structure of the debate event itself; the rules under which the participants agree to follow (or not as was the case in this year's first presidential debate).
  2. The structure of each participants core positions or arguments.
  3. The structure of the attacks by each participant on the others positions or arguments. 
What Keywords will you catch in tonight's debate?
As we stated in a previous post, Politics are based primarily around information and communication; so it stands to reason that a debate in some sense resembles an information architecture. The determination as to who wins a debate is a fairly subjective exercise; what can be measured perhaps is how "well-architected" their approach (and delivery is). So what does that mean? If we look back at the three main components of Debate Architecture listed above then we might provide some subjective measures based upon:
  • Whether the candidate / participant was able to work effectively within the rules; e.g. were they able to provide arguments and responses within the allotted time-frames or did they constantly run over time. Were they able to get their point across within their own sections or did they feel it necessary to interrupt the opponent/s during theirs?
  • Did the participants' arguments make sense; either in the context of their political ideology, their platform or the precise questions being posed during the debate (and hopefully across all of these contexts).
  • Were the participants able to respond or defuse their opponents' arguments or did the participants simply talk past those - perhaps repeating key phrases or slogans that address the topic generally but not the specific arguments made during that debate.
How did they do last week? It depends on how you measure it...
These are just some of the ways we attempt to assess the outcomes of debates. If we were to take it a step further, perhaps we could even diagram some of this out. For example, we might consider that each argument or political theme has multiple dimensions; for example a political one, an economic one and a personal one.
  • The Political Dimension – This represents how people view their government as well as political values & philosophies.
  • The Economic Dimension – This dimension represents how people view economic policy and philosophy.
  • The Personal Dimension – This dimensions captures the personal expectations of constituents as well as a general sense of what the “individual” represents within a society.
Not every argument or issue will span all three of dimensions but surprisingly most of them do. For example, one might think that a social issue ought to reside primarily in the personal dimension but what if part of the argument addresses government regulation of that social issue and another directly affects national or state budgets?



An Ontology can provide an organizing framework for all information associated with a domain
Arguments can be built using Dimensions at a high level, but what about at the the detail level? That's where having an organized approach to managing a large set of complex and inter-related knowledge comes in very handy. One of the best ways to do that is through use of Ontology (see the illustration above). Who knows whether either candidate will bring their A game tonight - but perhaps the real question is - do they have a game plan?


Copyright 2012, Semantech Inc. All rights Reserved